« previous next »
Pages: 1 [2]

Author Topic: Rear Wiper - MOT  (Read 6542 times)

Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #15 on: December 05, 2010, 12:05:00 PM
No, you should be fine.
If you take the wiper arm off, then it could possibly be a fail as there would be a protrusion that could be dangerous to n00bish pedestrians.
Logged
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #16 on: December 05, 2010, 12:30:49 PM
Quote from: soopahfly
Quote from: filbert
Quote from: soopahfly
Spare tyre CAN be an MOT fail if its bald, but its not required.
If its bald, take it out.

If its fitted, it must work.


No no no no no wrong


No no no no right.

If its bald and you leave it in the car at test time, it can be a fail.
As its not a requirement, you can remove it.

But like I said, If its fitted, Its got to work.

I fell foul of this when I took my old Delica to one of those Council run MOT places that the ambulance and Police use.
I failed for bald spare tyre and non functioning spot lights.
Removed the spare, covered the spots, retested and passed.


Quote from: soopahfly
8.2 Wipers and Washers
http://www.motuk.co.uk/manual_820.htm




Quote from: soopahfly
No, you should be fine.
If you take the wiper arm off, then it could possibly be a fail as there would be a protrusion that could be dangerous to n00bish pedestrians.


Why do you persist when you clearly dont know.
whoever failed your spare was wrong, its NOT a testable item
Your link to section 8.2 clearly states *windscreen* no mention of rear window, the rear wiper is NOT a testable item
Any protrusion can only fail if its corroded, as the rear wiper isnt tested it doesnt matter either way.
Logged
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #17 on: December 05, 2010, 12:42:42 PM
Quote from: filbert
Quote from: soopahfly
Quote from: filbert
Quote from: soopahfly
Spare tyre CAN be an MOT fail if its bald, but its not required.
If its bald, take it out.

If its fitted, it must work.


No no no no no wrong


No no no no right.

If its bald and you leave it in the car at test time, it can be a fail.
As its not a requirement, you can remove it.

But like I said, If its fitted, Its got to work.

I fell foul of this when I took my old Delica to one of those Council run MOT places that the ambulance and Police use.
I failed for bald spare tyre and non functioning spot lights.
Removed the spare, covered the spots, retested and passed.


Quote from: soopahfly
8.2 Wipers and Washers
http://www.motuk.co.uk/manual_820.htm




Quote from: soopahfly
No, you should be fine.
If you take the wiper arm off, then it could possibly be a fail as there would be a protrusion that could be dangerous to n00bish pedestrians.


Why do you persist when you clearly dont know.
whoever failed your spare was wrong, its NOT a testable item
Your link to section 8.2 clearly states *windscreen* no mention of rear window, the rear wiper is NOT a testable item
Any protrusion can only fail if its corroded, as the rear wiper isnt tested it doesnt matter either way.




Id prefer to take my advice from a proper council run MOT station, than whatever bodger you use.

I never said that the rear wiper was a failure, just that potentially it could be under the "if its fitted it must work" category, I posted the link to the MOT testers manual to show that it wasnt.
Ive run enough ropey cars in my life to know what things do actually constitute a failure or an advisory.
Logged

  • Offline shofty

  • Posts: 847
  • Hero Member
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #18 on: December 05, 2010, 13:09:23 PM
if its fitted it must work. take the spindle off and youre laughing.

thats not internet hearsay, thats from my friend the mot tester who loosley tests all my motors.

however not all testers bother reading the rulebook,hence why this argument is devloping in this thread.
Logged

  • Offline Beaker

  • Posts: 3,803
  • Hero Member
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #19 on: December 05, 2010, 13:15:28 PM
Quote from: soopahfly
Id prefer to take my advice from a proper council run MOT station, than whatever bodger you use.

I never said that the rear wiper was a failure, just that potentially it could be under the "if its fitted it must work" category, I posted the link to the MOT testers manual to show that it wasnt.
Ive run enough ropey cars in my life to know what things do actually constitute a failure or an advisory.


If a tester is telling you that then you need to go to a different test station, as he clearly doesnt know what hes talking about.

From your suggested website ::
"This inspection applies to

Tyres fitted to the road wheels only.  The vehicle presenter should be informed when it is noticed that there is a defective tyre on a spare wheel."

http://www.motuk.co.uk/manual_410.htm

AA Website ::

"Spare tyre

There is no legal obligation to carry a spare tyre and it does not have to comply with the legal requirements while it is stowed away. However, when fitted to the vehicle (for example, following a puncture) it must then comply with the law. A spare tyre is not a testable item in the MOT test, though the examiner may draw your attention to an unserviceable item as a matter of courtesy. "

http://www.theaa.com/motoring_advice/legal-advice/tyres.html

Department For Transport PDF document ::

"Tyres and wheels: Condition, security, tyre size/type and tread depth.
Spare tyres are not inspected."

http://www.dft.gov.uk/vosa/repository/CONT071791.pdf
Logged
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #20 on: December 05, 2010, 15:17:45 PM
Quote from: soopahfly
Quote from: filbert
Quote from: soopahfly
Quote from: filbert
Quote from: soopahfly
Spare tyre CAN be an MOT fail if its bald, but its not required.
If its bald, take it out.

If its fitted, it must work.


No no no no no wrong


No no no no right.

If its bald and you leave it in the car at test time, it can be a fail.
As its not a requirement, you can remove it.

But like I said, If its fitted, Its got to work.

I fell foul of this when I took my old Delica to one of those Council run MOT places that the ambulance and Police use.
I failed for bald spare tyre and non functioning spot lights.
Removed the spare, covered the spots, retested and passed.


Quote from: soopahfly
8.2 Wipers and Washers
http://www.motuk.co.uk/manual_820.htm




Quote from: soopahfly
No, you should be fine.
If you take the wiper arm off, then it could possibly be a fail as there would be a protrusion that could be dangerous to n00bish pedestrians.


Why do you persist when you clearly dont know.
whoever failed your spare was wrong, its NOT a testable item
Your link to section 8.2 clearly states *windscreen* no mention of rear window, the rear wiper is NOT a testable item
Any protrusion can only fail if its corroded, as the rear wiper isnt tested it doesnt matter either way.




Id prefer to take my advice from a proper council run MOT station, than whatever bodger you use.

I never said that the rear wiper was a failure, just that potentially it could be under the "if its fitted it must work" category, I posted the link to the MOT testers manual to show that it wasnt.
Ive run enough ropey cars in my life to know what things do actually constitute a failure or an advisory.


Ive worked in a garage all my working life, over 35 years, Ive been a mot tester for over 25 of them years, Ive been a quality controller over other testers for many years.

Like I said, why do you persist when you clearly dont know.  
Logged
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #21 on: December 05, 2010, 15:22:34 PM
Quote from: bytejunkie
if its fitted it must work. take the spindle off and youre laughing.

thats not internet hearsay, thats from my friend the mot tester who loosley tests all my motors.

however not all testers bother reading the rulebook,hence why this argument is devloping in this thread.


Your friend doesnt know what hes doing.
Logged

  • Offline Shaun

  • Posts: 724
  • Hero Member
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #22 on: December 06, 2010, 03:20:16 AM
 I had my car MOT’ed and serviced last May when I went to pick it up I asked if it had needed anything doing? he said he needed to replace the front wiper blades, so I asked him if the back one was ok? his reply was they don’t look at it for the MOT.
Logged

  • Offline Eagle

  • Posts: 1,902
  • Hero Member
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #23 on: December 08, 2010, 00:12:10 AM
MOTd mine in March.  Bribed the garage.  Simples.
Logged

  • Offline Bacon

  • Lettuce Tomato
  • Posts: 5,345
  • Global Moderator
  • Hero Member
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #24 on: December 08, 2010, 09:14:23 AM
Car in question
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/2002-BMW-316TI-SE-COMPACT-BLUE-/120657531841?pt=Automobiles_UK&hash=item1c17bfd3c1#payId

It ended yesterday on £1600, without reaching its reserve.

Today it gets relisted and funnily enough has 18 bids already, by 2 new ebay users, which has taken it upto you guessed it £1600.

I wont be bothering now.
Logged
Insert signature here.
Re:Rear Wiper - MOT
Reply #25 on: December 08, 2010, 11:22:56 AM
when we got my little sisters first car she complained that the rear wiper didnt work very well. Dad and I had a look at it and the rubber was completely warn away, I think it was the original factory fit blade (car was 10+ years old at the time). If that passed an MOT, Id say they dont check them!
Logged
Pages: 1 [2]
« previous next »

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.