I would give up on one source m8, silly been looking at myself and one source will say its one way and then the other.

End of the day only real testimant is when they are properly main stream market and joe blogs buys them

Long way off mainstream yet apparently
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=40457
Do not think that late but not till at least next year

Still cant see blue-ray being the choice in terms of burning though, pc wise when it finally moves and cost etc I just see hd being the choice and sad and funny say but probably true dvd copy folk would make a big chunk of which wins.

I think basically

- Joe Blogs
- Porn
- PC Folk
- Movies
- Gaming idustry
- Misc

Are the ones that will make or break either one (in that order)

Funny, you do all that imperical research and I go to the driving range...we both come to the same conclusion; we were wrong

At least we both realised we were wrong

Id love to have swapped my research way for yours, then again I was getting paid while I did mine hehe

The other 70% because they wanted to future proof themselves.

I reckon most people bought them cause they look swanky and saw them on MTV cribs or something lol.

Quote from: neXus

Long way off mainstream yet apparently

Without a doubt. I would say only 30% of HDTV owners bought one for HDTV & for the new media format, Sky HD, etc.

The other 70% because they wanted to future proof themselves.
not a specialised unit.

A few, like me, bought HDTVs for use as a computer monitor, and there must be others who wanted Sky HD on their set.

Quote from: Nimrod

Funny, you do all that imperical research and I go to the driving range...we both come to the same conclusion; we were wrong

At least we both realised we were wrong

Id love to have swapped my research way for yours, then again I was getting paid while I did mine hehe

So was I

Got to love the freedoms of working from home

You do have to take the BBC article with a pinch of salt.  Block buster will continue to do HD-DVD in the 250 stores which currently run HD-DVD rental.  Also, the BBC continues to refer to Bluray as as Bluray DVD...

This story made me laugh, they refer to Bluray as DVD and claim the DVD market is "slowing".  My arse.  I say story, but I use it in the vaguest possible sense.

At the moment I will choose Bluray over HD-DVD if they are the same price and region free so I can get 1:1 pixel mapping on my HDTV.  VGA has 2% overscan so it is slightly stretched.  

I believe the one film studio that was HD-DVD has announced that they will be doing Bluray as well.  Either way, if you have both formats then you are going to get the best version of the movie.  If you are going to pick one, you should pick the one which has available the movies that you want to watch.

The problem I forsee is that the slow take up of both bluray and hd-dvd will mean that the market for them will still be considerably smaller than the DVD market.  Movie companies want to move to the new formats because of the new copy protection to prevent piracy (short lived...).  I dont see DVD leaving us for a long time.  Its cheap, Cheap, CHEAP.  I cant help but think the HD formats will be for the enthusiast for quite a long time.

Thing is a number of the film companies Bluray only will start shipping HDdvd versions as well

None of them seem to really know which will be the best and there is going to be a lot of money and deals exchanging hands and being made

I think Universal are HD-DVD Only & Disney Blu-Ray Only
The rest are cross platform.
I wouldnt be suprised if we start to see dual sided discs. Blu-Ray on oneside & HD-DVD the other.

The only list I can find :-

Blu-ray support
     
Paramount
Warner Bros.
Disney (Buena Vista)
Fox
Lionsgate
MGM
Sony Pictures
      
HD-DVD support

Paramount
Warner Bros.
Universal Studios

I really look forward to the day when physical distribution via disks is no longer mainstream

Stream or download all your content, stored in one box locally or when ever you need it from your supplier, whether its games, music, tv, movies, software etc.

We really need to dig all that copper out.