pretty much comes down to asus or gigabyte.... I pick gigabyte every time now.... last few asus boards have really sucked
(or been DOA)
other than that... they're all pretty much the same... it won;t make much difference which one you pick...
but if you're going to use some of your old components... watch out because not all new boards have IDE some are SATA only :-)
(p.s. wb :-) )